Lake Superior Pizza Subs & Specialties Menu
The first time I walked into Lake Superior Pizza Subs & Specialties, I was soaked from a sudden storm off the lake and hungry enough to eat a menu. I ordered the first thing t...
The first time I walked into Lake Superior Pizza Subs & Specialties, I was soaked from a sudden storm off the lake and hungry enough to eat a menu. I ordered the first thing that sounded warm and forgiving. That turned out to be a sub, not a pizza—and that’s when I learned this place isn’t a one-trick dough show.
Maybe you’ve had that moment, too. You expect a pizza joint, then the menu keeps going. And going. It’s like someone said, “Why choose?” and built a restaurant around the answer.
The Pizza Menu: Familiar, But Not Boring
Pizza is still the anchor here. You can go classic with cheese or pepperoni, or build something loaded with sausage, mushrooms, onions, and peppers. If you’re indecisive, you’re in good company—half the room is staring at the same laminated menu.
Must Read
The crust matters. Thin, hand-tossed, maybe a crispy edge if you ask nicely. The sauce leans a little sweet, a little tangy, the kind that makes you reach for a napkin and another slice.
Specialty pies are where the kitchen shows off. Think meat-lover’s chaos, veggie garden, or a Supreme that weighs more than your keys. You can sometimes order by the slice, but don’t count on it during a Friday rush.
Subs: The Sleeper Hit
Here’s the thing: the subs might be the real reason regulars keep coming back. Hot or cold, they’re built on bread that actually holds up. You know how sad a soggy sub is—this isn’t that.
Italian, steak and cheese, chicken, meatball, turkey, ham and cheese—the usual suspects line up. Add lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, banana peppers, oil and vinegar, mayo, mustard, or hot sauce. The staff will ask what you want, and you should answer honestly.
Pro tip: If you’re splitting one, ask them to cut it. If you’re not splitting one, still ask them to cut it. You’ll feel more civilized, even if you eat both halves in the car.
Online Menu of Lake Superior Pizza Subs & Specialties Restaurant
Specialties: The Wild Card Section
This is the part of the menu that makes you tilt your head. Specialties can mean wings, calzones, salads, pasta, or a rotating cast of local comfort food. Around Lake Superior, that might include fish, pasties, or something smothered in gravy. Yes, gravy. You’re in the Midwest now.
Wings come saucy, spicy, or mild enough for your aunt who thinks black pepper is aggressive. Salads exist, and they’re not just sad afterthoughts—though you didn’t come here for kale, did you?
Calzones are basically pizzas folded like a secret. If you order one, expect leftovers, or expect to lie about having leftovers. We’ve all been there.
Sides That Deserve Their Own Fan Club
Sides might include garlic bread, cheese bread, fries, onion rings, or mozzarella sticks. These are the supporting actors that sometimes steal the scene. Order the cheese bread. You’ll thank me later.
Drinks are simple: soda, iced tea, maybe beer if they serve it. Refills depend on the day and the server’s patience. Be nice, and good things happen.
Lake Superior Pizza Subs & Specialties - Marquette, MI
How to Order Without Regret
First, decide whether you’re in a pizza mood or a sub mood. If you’re with a group, order both and call it “family style.” If you’re alone, order a small pizza and a sub, then realize you’ve made a beautiful mistake.
Second, ask about daily specials. Small places like this often have deals that aren’t on the main menu. You might save a few bucks or discover a new favorite.
Third, remember that this isn’t fast food, even if it feels casual. Good pizza and subs take a few minutes. Use that time to people-watch or argue about toppings.
Why the Menu Works
Lake Superior Pizza Subs & Specialties doesn’t try to be fancy. It tries to be useful. You can feed a family, a crew, or just yourself after a long day. The menu covers cravings without making you feel like you need a translator.
Sure, the name is a mouthful. But so is the Italian sub. And honestly? That’s the point.
Next time you’re near the lake and your stomach growls, give it a shot. Order the pizza, the sub, and maybe a specialty. You’ll leave full and already planning your next order.
