Streets Of New York Fountain Hills Menu

If you’re looking for the Streets of New York menu in Fountain Hills, Arizona, congratulations: you’ve found the carb-based equivalent of a hug. This place serves New York-style pizza without the rude cab drivers or the mysterious puddle on the sidewalk. It’s a local chain, not a Broadway musical, but the garlic knots deserve a standing ovation.

Fountain Hills itself is famous for that giant fountain that shoots water hundreds of feet into the desert sky. Yes, hundreds. The town’s fountain can hit around 560 feet, which is taller than the Statue of Liberty. So you can eat a slice and watch a water column show off like it’s trying to impress your date.

The Appetizer Situation

Start with garlic knots, because starting with salad is a rookie move. These doughy little hand grenades arrive slick with garlic butter and parmesan, and they vanish faster than your resolution to save room for pizza. Order two baskets. Trust me. You’ll thank me, then blame me for your garlic breath.

Mozzarella sticks are the classic choice, fried until they achieve that perfect snap and stretch. Chicken wings come in mild, hot, BBQ, and garlic parmesan, which is basically a flavor group hug. If you’re feeling fancy, bruschetta offers tomatoes and basil, as if vegetables can undo the fried cheese.

Salads, Because Balance Is a Lie

The menu includes salads like Caesar, Greek, and antipasto. They’re perfectly fine, and they do come in a bowl, which makes them officially healthy. But let’s be honest: you don’t drive to a New York-style pizza place for kale. You drive there for mozzarella that pulls like taffy.

The Main Event: Pizza

Now, the pizza. Streets of New York does thin crust and hand-tossed, by the slice or by the pie. Sizes range from small to large to “I have made questionable life choices.” You can build your own with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, and anchovies for the one person at the table who likes salty little fish.

Specialty pies include The Works, which is every topping except the kitchen sink. There’s also white pizza, margherita, BBQ chicken, meat lovers, and veggie. The crust has that foldable, chewy snap that New Yorkers claim is impossible outside the five boroughs. Arizona doesn’t care. Arizona just keeps eating.

Streets of New York, Fountain Hills - Restaurant menu, prices and reviews

Surprising fact: New York-style pizza’s famous texture is often blamed on NYC water. Scientists say it’s mostly about dough technique and high heat. So you can stop smuggling tap water in your luggage. The Fountain Hills location gets it right anyway.

Calzones, Stromboli, and Subs

If pizza isn’t enough—and it never is—try a calzone. It’s a pizza folded like a sleeping bag, stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and whatever toppings you desire. Stromboli is the rolled cousin, sliced into rounds, and it’s basically a savory cinnamon roll that went to college.

Subs include Italian, meatball, chicken parm, eggplant parm, and sausage and peppers. They arrive on soft rolls with enough filling to require a strategic nap afterward. Napkins are not optional. They are a lifestyle.

Pasta and Desserts

Pasta options run from spaghetti and meatballs to fettuccine Alfredo, baked ziti, and lasagna. These are the dishes you order when you want to feel like a character in a mob movie, but with less worrying about federal wiretaps. The portions are generous, which is a polite way of saying “bring a friend or a very large purse.”

Fountain Hills, AZ - Shea Blvd & Saguaro Blvd - Streets of New York

Desserts usually include cheesecake and cannoli, maybe tiramisu, depending on the day. Cheesecake is dense enough to anchor a small boat. Cannoli is crispy, creamy, and gone before you can say “I’ll just have one bite.”

Pro Tips for Fountain Hills

Call ahead for takeout if you’re hungry enough to eat the menu itself. The Fountain Hills location can get busy, especially when the fountain is doing its dramatic eruption thing. Check the eruption schedule if you want dinner and a show.

Parking is generally easy, and the vibe is casual. You can show up in a T-shirt, flip-flops, or full desert hiking gear. No one will judge. They’re too busy staring at your pizza.

So there you have it: the Streets of New York Fountain Hills menu is a tour of Italian-American comfort food with a New York accent. It won’t fix your rent, your love life, or the fact that you just ate an entire large pizza. But it will make you very, very happy. And honestly? That’s a pretty good deal.