Mr T's Pizza & Ice Cream Menu

I once walked into Mr T's Pizza & Ice Cream intending to grab a quick slice. Forty minutes later, I was debating pineapple on pizza while holding a melting hot fudge sundae. If that sounds like a personal failure, you clearly haven’t seen the menu.

This is not a place that asks you to choose between dinner and dessert. It hands you both and says, “Figure it out, champ.”

The Menu Is Two Restaurants in One Apron

Mr T's doesn’t pretend to be a fancy bistro. It’s a pizza joint and an old-school ice cream counter sharing the same cash register. The result feels like a childhood sleepover and a Friday night takeout order had a baby.

You can order a large pepperoni pizza and a banana split in the same breath. Nobody behind the counter will judge you. Your cardiologist might, but that’s a separate conversation.

Pizza: The Usual Suspects and a Few Curveballs

The pizza side covers the classics without making you feel basic. Thin, thick, or whatever crust your heart demands. Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and olives are all present and accounted for.

Then come the specialty pies. Some lean meaty, some veggie, and a few sound like a late-night dare. You know the type: barbecue chicken, buffalo chicken, bacon cheeseburger, and something with ranch that shouldn’t work but does.

Build Your Own, Or Let Them Decide

Build your own if you need control. Pick the size, sauce, cheese, and toppings. Extra cheese is not a crime, and Mr T's understands that.

If you’re indecisive, order a specialty pizza and call it a personality test. Maybe you’re “supreme” or “white pizza with spinach.” Either way, you eat.

Sides That Steal the Show

Garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, wings, fries, and salads round out the pizza half. The garlic knots arrive warm, greasy, and impossible to stop eating.

Mr. T's Pizza & Ice Cream, Chattanooga - Menu, Reviews (553), Photos

Wings come in the usual flavors, from mild to “sign a waiver.” The salads are there for balance, which is cute. Order one if you must; I won’t tell.

Ice Cream: The Plot Twist

Here’s where Mr T's gets sneaky. Just when you’ve accepted it as a pizza place, the ice cream menu hits like a sugar rush. Cones, cups, sundaes, floats, shakes, and freezes are all fair game, and flavors rotate while the classics hang around.

Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, butter pecan, mint chip, cookies and cream, and cookie dough are the usual suspects. Then there’s a wildcard or two, like birthday cake. Yes, you can get sprinkles.

The Freezer Case Is a Time Machine

If you grew up with a neighborhood ice cream shop, the freezer case will feel familiar. Scoops are generous and whipped cream is applied with reckless abandon, so you don’t come for tiny artisan portions. You come for a sundae that requires a spoon and a plan.

Milkshakes are thick enough to stand a spoon in. Floats fizz like a science experiment you can drink. The banana split is basically a pizza box’s dessert cousin: oversized, shareable, and slightly ridiculous.

How to Order Without Regret

Decide whether pizza is the main event or the warm-up. If ice cream is the goal, split a small pizza and save room. If pizza is the goal, add a scoop and call it balanced.

MR T'S PIZZA AND ICE CREAM, Chattanooga - Menu, Prices & Restaurant

Don’t order a large pizza for two unless you enjoy leftovers. Future you will thank present you at 11 p.m.

Ask about the flavor of the day. You might find a new favorite—or learn you hate maple bacon ice cream.

The Vibe on the Side

Mr T's feels casual, loud, and family-friendly in the best way. Kids get excited about ice cream, adults get excited about not cooking, and teenagers get a place to exist without buying a $14 smoothie.

It’s not trying to be trendy. It’s trying to feed you.

Final Bite

The Mr T's Pizza & Ice Cream menu is a beautiful contradiction. It’s carb-heavy, dairy-forward, and unapologetic. You come for a slice, stay for a sundae, and leave wondering why more places don’t do both.

So go hungry. Go with someone who won’t steal your garlic knots. And if you can’t decide between pizza and ice cream, relax: you can have both.